Before we look at how a divorce in same-sex marriage may be different it is critical that we understand how a marriage between tow individuals of the same gender is recognized and viewed throughout the United States. While same-sex marriage is legally recognized everywhere in the U.S., the underlying state laws create a patchwork that can affect couples in subtle but important ways, some still harboring dormant bans—creates real-world differences for couples, especially when it comes to divorce and family stability.
Even though same-sex marriage has been legal across the United States since the Supreme Court’s landmark Obergefell v. Hodges decision in 2015, the way individual states treat these marriages beneath the surface can vary dramatically. In many states, old constitutional amendments or statutes that define marriage as exclusively between a man and a woman remain on the books—these are known as "dormant bans." They’re unenforceable for now, but their presence can create confusion and anxiety for same-sex couples, especially in politically volatile times. As of 2026, over 30 U.S. states still have dormant constitutional or statutory bans against same-sex marriage on their books, which remain entirely unenforceable under the U.S. Supreme Court's 2015
On the other hand, a growing number of states have taken proactive steps to affirmatively protect marriage equality. States like California, New York, Colorado, and Hawaii have updated their laws or constitutions to explicitly guarantee the right of same-sex couples to marry, regardless of what happens at the federal level. For couples living in these states, there’s an added layer of security and clarity—marriage equality is not just a federal mandate, but a state right as well.
This is a three-part blog series that will discuss the underlying law and how California handles same-sex divorces and how it has stepped up to protect those couples who may find themselves in a state that does not afford them the same protections. Part one of this series covers what problems come up in California because the spouses are the same sex. Part two will cover what happens if you married in California but live somewhere that won't end the marriage. In part three we will provide a Q&A format.
Same-sex Divorces in California
On paper, a same-sex divorce in Los Angeles or Orange County looks like any other. The petition is the same. So is the rule that a divorce can't become final until at least six months has past. A judge divides property under the same community property law that applies to every married couple in the state.
The differences show up in the couple's history. Plenty of same-sex couples spent ten or twenty years together before the law let them marry. Some registered as domestic partners first. Some married during the few months in 2008 when California allowed it, then again years later. Many had children through donor insemination or surrogacy, which means one parent has a biological tie and the other doesn't. None of that changes the statutes a judge applies. It can change the outcome a great deal.
The legal ground in 2026
The U.S. Supreme Court's 2015 decision in Obergefell v. Hodges requires every state to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples and to recognize same-sex marriages performed in other states (Justia, Obergefell v. Hodges, 576 U.S. 644). Once a state has to treat a marriage as valid, it has to let the couple end it the same way it would any other marriage.
Congress passed the Respect for Marriage Act in December 2022. The law repealed the old Defense of Marriage Act and requires every state to honor a marriage validly entered in another state, regardless of the spouses' sex, race, ethnicity, or national origin (Public Law 117-228, Congress.gov). What it doesn't do is require a state to issue licenses on its own. If Obergefell ever fell, that gap would matter.
California offers even another layer of protection as voters closed a gap of their own in November 2024. Proposition 3 added a right to marry. It passed with 9,477,435 votes, or 62.6% (California Secretary of State, Statement of Vote, November 5, 2024; Official Voter Information Guide, Proposition 3).
At the federal level, the most recent attempt to overturn Obergefell failed. On November 10, 2025, the Supreme Court turned away a petition from Kim Davis, the former Kentucky county clerk who refused to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples (ABC News). ABC also reported that at least nine states saw bills or resolutions in 2025 aimed at blocking new licenses for same-sex couples or urging the Court to reconsider.
So, legally, a same-sex divorce in California is an ordinary divorce. What makes these cases harder is the timeline, the kids, and the address.
This isn't a small group of people. The 2020 Census counted 162,914 same-sex couples in California, and 61.3% of them were married. Los Angeles County had 45,117 same-sex couples, Orange County had 9,208, and about 15% to 16% of the couples in each county were raising children (Williams Institute, UCLA School of Law).
Problems that come up because the spouses are the same sex
The date the marriage started
Ask most divorcing spouses when they got married and they'll give you the same answer. For a lot of same-sex couples, the answer depends on who's asking and why.
California is a Community Property State that divides property, assets, and liabilities by dates. What either spouse acquired during the marriage, and anything bought with that money, belongs to both spouses equally. What a spouse owned before the wedding, or earned after separating, is that spouse's separate property (California Courts Self-Help Guide, Property and Debts in a Divorce). Picture a couple who met in 1998, bought a house together in 2003, and married in 2015. They shared a life for close to two decades. The law sees a much shorter marriage.
Spousal support is where that gap tends to hurt first. Family Code section 4336 presumes that a marriage lasting ten years or more, counted from the wedding to the date of separation, is a marriage "of long duration." In those cases, the court can keep authority over support indefinitely. The same statute lets a judge find that a shorter marriage is long duration based on the evidence (Justia, Cal. Fam. Code § 4336). That gives a lower-earning spouse something to argue with. It doesn't promise a result.
Courts across the country haven't agreed on how to treat the years before a wedding that the law wouldn't have allowed
Retirement savings follow the same calendar. A spouse has a right to part of a retirement plan only to the extent the money was earned during the marriage (California Courts Self-Help Guide, Property and Debts in a Divorce). If one partner spent 15 years building a pension before the wedding, those years generally aren't shared.
The house raises its own questions. When community money pays down the mortgage on a home one spouse bought before the marriage, the California Supreme Court held in In re Marriage of Moore (1980) that the community earns a share of that property. Payments made before the wedding don't create that community share, though, even if both partners made them.
For the years before marriage, California has one more tool. In Marvin v. Marvin (1976), the state Supreme Court ruled that unmarried partners can enforce agreements about property and support, whether those agreements were written down or simply understood from how the couple lived. A partner who stopped working to raise children, helped build a business, or put money into a house before the wedding may be able to bring a Marvin claim. These claims live or die on evidence. Joint bank statements, emails about buying property "for us," and wills naming each other can all help.
Domestic partnerships, 2008 marriages, and second weddings
California's domestic partner registry dates to 1999, when AB 26 let couples register with the Secretary of State. The early version offered little beyond hospital visitation and health benefits for partners of public employees. AB 205 changed that, giving registered partners close to the full set of spousal rights, including community property, starting January 1, 2005
The California Supreme Court struck down the state's marriage ban in May 2008. Voters passed Proposition 8 that November. In Strauss v. Horton (2009), the court upheld Proposition 8 but ruled that the roughly 18,000 marriages performed before it passed were still valid. Same-sex weddings didn't resume until June 2013, two days after the U.S. Supreme Court's ruling in Hollingsworth v. Perry.
That history leaves some couples with two or three legal relationships to each other. One couple might hold a 2004 domestic partnership and a 2014 marriage. Another might have married in 2008 and held a second ceremony later. Each document can point to a different start date, and the difference can be worth a lot of money.
A domestic partnership is its own legal status. Divorcing a spouse doesn't wipe out a domestic partnership with that same person unless the court is asked to end both. Family Code section 299 allows couples who are both registered partners and married to "dissolve both their domestic partnership and their marriage in a single proceeding.”
Generally, an earlier start date helps the spouse who earned less or whose name isn't on the assets, and a later date helps the other spouse. Gather every registration certificate and marriage certificate before sitting down with a lawyer or mediator.
When only one parent has a biological tie
Custody fights are painful in any divorce. In some same-sex divorces, there's an earlier question: is the non-biological parent legally a parent?
Under California law, Family Code Section 7611, the answer is usually yes. A spouse or domestic partner of the person who gives birth is presumed to be a parent of the child. The Family Code Section 7613 provides when a child is conceived with donor sperm or eggs and the other intended parent consented, that parent "is treated in law as if that intended parent is the natural parent"
Family lawyers still tend to recommend a court judgment or an adoption for the non-biological parent. A presumption can be challenged. A birth certificate is a record, not a court order. A judgment from a court, on the other hand, has to be honored by other states. The U.S. Supreme Court made that clear in V.L. v. E.L. (2016), when it unanimously reversed the Alabama Supreme Court for refusing to recognize a Georgia adoption by a mother's same-sex partner.
California has made those adoptions easier. Under Family Code section 9000.5, when a child was born during the marriage or partnership, a court can skip the home study and the hearing, and the couple doesn't need to have been married for any minimum length of time. The parentage presumption still applies; the adoption adds a court order on top of it.
If no adoption or parentage judgment exists and you're heading into a divorce, bring it up early. Spouses who get along can agree to a parentage judgment as part of the case. In a contested divorce, the biological parent may argue that the other spouse isn't a legal parent at all, and the court has to settle that before it reaches custody. CNBC's reporting described that risk, noting that a partner without legal parent status can end up cut off from a child they helped raise (CNBC).
Surrogacy follows a different path. The State of California Website states that parents who used a surrogate can't sign a Voluntary Declaration of Parentage, since the person who gave birth has to be one of the signers. Intended parents in a gestational carrier arrangement instead get a court judgment of parentage, which can be issued before or after the birth. Two dads going through a divorce should find that judgment and put it in the file before anyone argues about custody.
Social Security's ten-year rule
The Social Security Administration states that a divorced spouse can collect Social Security benefits on a former spouse's work record only if the marriage lasted at least ten years. A couple who married in 2016 and split in 2024 won't meet that test, even if they'd been together since the 1990s.
Surviving partners have had better luck. After two class actions, Thornton and Ely, the Social Security Administration now has to consider whether a surviving same-sex partner would have married sooner if the law had allowed it. Those cases were about survivor benefits. They didn't change the ten-year requirement for divorced spouses.
Timing, then, can matter. A couple a year or two away from their tenth anniversary may want to talk through whether to wait, or whether a legal separation makes more sense for now.
Other States
While California clearly has taken independent steps to enshrine and protect the rights of same-sex couples, the rest of America is not as enlightened. The next blog in this series will discuss the impact that it can have on same-sex couples.
Again: this article provides general information about California law and Los Angeles County procedure, not legal advice for your situation.
We understand that the divorce process with its unique rules and jargon can be confusing. DivvyLaw wants to help you better understand and navigate family law issues in Los Angeles and Orange Counties. If you would like to be notified of upcoming blogs and added to a waitlist for access to a revolutionary solution, click the link below to join our list.